Pie lovers rejoice! New York City is home to some of the best places to enjoy pie in all its delicious varieties. From classic apple and strawberry to unique flavors like chicken pot and salted caramel, the Big Apple slices up an array of sweet and savory pies to please all palates. Whether you’re looking for a piece of classic Americana, like apple pie; or a dish from a foreign culture, like the traditional Greek spanakopita – there is an amazing variety of pies available in the city.
Here are some of the best spots to indulge in a slice of pie in New York City.
Four & Twenty Blackbirds
Four & Twenty Blackbirds is consistently rated as one of the best places for pies in NYC. It is renowned for its classic and experimental flavors, with staples like salted honey, banoffee and chocolate chess mixed in with some wilder concoctions like sour cherry sage and hibiscus strawberry. Every component of the pies is made from scratch in the bakery, giving it an added homemade taste that is oh-so-good. Not to mention the spectacular presentation – this pie is as much as a delight to the eyes as it is to the tongue.
Eileen’s Special Cheesecake
For those who are specifically craving a sweet treat, Eileen’s Special Cheesecake is the place to go. This small, full-service establishment offers a delicious selection of cakes, pies, pastries and more. The star here is unquestionably the cheesecakes – available in flavors ranging from classic New York to Chocolate Decadence – but the other pies are nothing to laugh at. From Key Lime to Apple Crumb, here you will find the perfect blend of sweet and savory, with options to suit everybody’s taste.
Ovenly
Ovenly is a chic, modern bakery located in Greenpoint. The masterminds behind this sweet shop specialize in creating savory and vegan pastries that are both visually stunning and mouthwatering. While the store has a enormous range of tempting morsels on offer, the classic pies reign supreme. From quirky twists on classics like Key Lime to utterly unique innovations like rhubarb honey, Ovenly is an ideal place for pie-lovers looking for something modern and unexpected.
Pie Corps
Pie Corps is the ideal place for pie-lovers who are looking for a rustic, homespun experience. This bodega-style shop offers a small range of traditional pies, such as apple, strawberry, peach and pecan. Classic ingredients are fresh, organic, and locally sourced, and each pie is crafted by hand with care. Pie Corps also works with special orders, so if you have a special occasion coming up they can whip you up a custom pie to fit your exact needs.
Eileen’s Bakery
Family owned since 1980, Eileen’s Bakery is a dependable source for all things pie. This old-school bakery offers classic pies, like Apple, Peach and Cherry, as well as some unique flavors like Bacon Iced Jam and Coconut Chess. All the pies are made from scratch, using classic recipes and the freshest ingredients. Whether you’re looking for a classic slice of nostalgic goodness, or something a bit more daring – there’s something here for everyone.
Green Grape
The Green Grape is a small family-run café in Chelsea that prides itself on brining a taste of the past to the present with its food. At Green Grape you can find delicious, homemade pies in a range of classic flavors. Whether you’re in the mood for food that’s simple and homey or something more experimental, the Green Grape could be your spot. The flavors range from comfort food like classic Southern style Sweet Potato Pie, to classic Greek Spanakopita.
Tiny’s Giant Sandwich Shop
Tiny’s Giant Sandwich Shop may be better known for its delightful sandwiches, but their pies are just as amazing. Both sweet and savory options are available, ranging from classics like the Apple Crumble Pie, to unique creations such as the Huckleberry Pie or the Curried Sweet Potato Pie. The pies are made with fresh, locally sourced ingredients and no preservatives. Plus, they are served in individual slices so you can take your pick.
Bubby’s
Bubby’s is an all-American classic, a true local favorite. This casual establishment has a menu full of decadent desserts and their pies are especially popular. A wide selection of flavors are available, ranging from sweet classics like Blueberry and Apple, to savory items like Chicken Pot Pie and the signature “BBQ Pork Pie.” No matter your preference the pies here are always freshly made and delicious, so you really can’t go wrong.
Emerald Inn
Last but not least, we have the Emerald Inn. This cozy neighborhood eatery serves pub-style food and most notably, slabs of freshly baked pies. From Bumbleberry Pie, to Chocolate Cream and even Pecan Pie, Emerald Inn has got a wide selection of pies to satisfy any craving. Each slice is overstuffed with its own unique flavor, making Emerald Inn the perfect spot for any pie-lover.
New York City has no shortage of amazing places for pie. Whether you’re looking for a classic American favorite or something a bit more adventurous, there are plenty of places serving up delicious pies of all types. So whether you want a traditional slice of apple crumble pie, or something more unique like a curried sweet potato – make sure to explore these spots and more on your hunt for a perfect flip-top box of delight.
