Thanksgiving is quickly approaching and the craving for a delicious, homemade pie is in the air. Though there are certainly plenty of top-notch frozen pies available from your local grocery store, they simply can’t compare to a true, handmade creation. If you’re in the mood for something extra special this holiday season, you’ll definitely be delighted with the many talented and creative bakeries Brooklyn, New York has to offer. Here are ten of the best to consider when placing your order for a signature Thanksgiving pie.
- Four & Twenty Blackbirds
As one of the most popular pie shops located in Brooklyn, Four & Twenty Blackbirds has gained quite a following since opening its doors in 2010. Their yummy creations—which include flavors such as salted caramel apple and Gimme S’more—are as pleasing to the eye as they are to the taste buds. Their holiday pies, which include Sweet Potato Pecan, Pumpkin and Bourbon, and Sour Cherry, can be ordered for pickup or shipped all over the country.
- Ovenly
Ovenly opened its Brooklyn location in 2011 and has quickly become a local favorite amongst Brooklynites and visitors alike. They offer an array of tantalizing treats—cupcakes, pastries, and of course, pies—such as Spiced Apple Crumb, Chocolate Cream, and Candied Cranberry Pear. Order your favorites for pickup or take advantage of their shipping services and enjoy the taste of Ovenly wherever you are.
- Bustling Bake Shop
If you’re looking for a variety of scrumptious pastries and pies, then you’ve just hit the jackpot with Bustling Bake Shop. Their pies—Sweet Potato Pecan, Banana Cream, Date & Walnut, and Persimmon Cream—are all easy on the eyes and have even been featured in the New York Times. They offer both pickup and delivery within a few miles of their Brooklyn location.
- Greyston Bakery
Established in 1982, Greyston Bakery is well-known for serving up people’s favorite flavors with a philanthropic purpose. All proceeds from their delicious treats—which include key lime cream, vegan chocolate, and caramel pecan pies—go to helping those in need. Look for your newly-ordered goodies up at their Brooklyn location or be sure to ask them about their delivery options.
- The Prospect Terrace Bakery
At The Prospect Terrace Bakery, guests can enjoy the satisfying combination of delicious pastries and stunning skyline views of downtown Brooklyn. Take advantage of their shipping or pickup options and pick up a classic Pumpkin Pie or maybe even something a bit twisty—like Cookies & Cream Pie or their Pumpkin Pie Re-Imagine-Ed specialty (pumpkin pie made with a homemade graham cracker crust).
- Little Cupcake Bakeshop
Though this particular bakery is more known for its decadent cupcakes, its pies are also an absolute hit. Little Cupcake Bakeshop has a nice selection to choose from including Apple, Coconut Cream, Pecan, and classic Pumpkin. Place your order for pickup or local delivery and be sure to keep an eye out for their festive specials this Thanksgiving season.
- Ledner Cakes & Pastries
Ledner Cakes & Pastries makes all of their signature treats “from scratch,” which gives the pies they make a truly delicious homemade taste. Their selection of delicious goodies includes classics such as Apple Pie, Sweet Potato Pie, and Custard Pie, as well as specialty treats like their Pistachio Macadamia Nut Pie or their unique Italian Ricotta Pie.
- Konditori
Konditori is a popular Swedish-inspired cafe whose Bakery has earned a big name in Brooklyn. Their famed Swedish Apple Pie—which is accompanied by crumbly streusel—is without a doubt one of the most delicious treats from their menu. While the pies can’t be shipped, they’re still available for pickup at their Cobble Hill location.
- Bake Cafe
Opened in 2011, Bake is a quaint little café that dishes out a range of colorful pastries, breads, and pies. Among the sweeter treats available is the popular Apple Pie, which is filled with a fragrant mix of braeburn apples, and their Pecan Pie, which is served with a delightful bourbon glaze. In addition to showcasing their baked goods, Bake also offers delivery services throughout Brooklyn.
- Pie Corps
If out-of-this world flavored pies are what you’re after, then you can’t go wrong with Pie Corps. This unique bakery offers pies unlike any other, with unusual flavors like pickles and cream and strawberry shortbread, as well as classic flavors like apple and blueberry. Place your order for pickup, shipping, or local delivery and indulge in your favorite flavor this Thanksgiving.
Tips for Enjoying the Best Brooklyn Pies this Thanksgiving
When ordering pies from one of the bakeries mentioned above, consider the following tips for getting the most out of your Thanksgiving experience:
• Don’t forget to ask about all the different flavors each bakery offers, as some may not list them all on their website.
• Don’t wait too long to place your order, as most of these bakeries get inundated with requests during the holiday season and may run out of popular items.
• When ordering for pickup, try to call ahead and let the bakery know what time you’ll be arriving.
• When ordering for local delivery, double-check that the address is correct and provide any helpful information to the delivery driver.
Brooklyn certainly has no shortage of talented and creative bakers who are more than willing to provide you and your family with a special homemade pie this Thanksgiving season. Be sure to take advantage of the many outstanding bakeries lined up in this article and make sure to put in your order ahead of time. Before you know it, you’ll be sinking your teeth in a delectable, one-of-a-kind creation that’ll leave you wishing Thanksgiving was celebrated more than once a year!
