New York City has so much to offer when it comes to dining out — from gourmet restaurants to casual eateries, there’s something for everyone. But sometimes its nice to kick it old-fashioned and get back to the real classic atmosphere of an old-school restaurant. If you’re looking for a nostalgic night out, NYC isn’t lacking in sweet spots.
Take a look below at the best old-school restaurants in the Big Apple to get that classic taste of good old-fashioned cooking.
- Ebinger’s
The first old-school restaurant on our list is none other than Ebinger’s, an iconic bakery in Brooklyn that used to be the talk of the town in the early 1900s. Ebinger’s became so popular for its classic black and white cookies, chocolate and butter cream cupcakes, and pastries, it eventually became a well-known staple in New York City. Now, decades after its original closure, Ebinger’s reopened in 2017 and still continues to draw in crowds with its classic cakes and cookies.
- Peter Luger Steak House
Since 1887, Peter Luger Steak House has been famous for one of New York City’s best steak dishes. Its classic menu has been delighting locals for years, with its prime aged steaks, freshly baked bread, and delicious sides. The restaurant also features a quaint old-fashioned atmosphere, great for giving you that time-warp dinner experience.
- Old Homestead Steakhouse
Recognized as one of NYC’s oldest steakhouse, Old Homestead Steakhouse has been around since 1868. Old Homestead has been in business for over 135 years, making it one of the oldest restaurants in New York City. The restaurant also features a classic atmosphere with its dark mahogany walls, deep booths and low lighting. Not to mention its classic menu featuring some of the best quality steakhouse fare.
- Totonno’s Pizzeria Napolitano
If you’re a pizza lover, don’t forget to check out Totonno’s Pizzeria Napolitano. This old-school restaurant has been around since 1924, serving up some of the best classic pizza in the city. Totonno’s is renowned for its hand-sliced thin crust, made with fresh specially-blended ingredients. Perfect for that authentic feel of NYC pizza.
- Grimaldi’s Pizzeria
Grimaldi’s Pizzeria is another classic NYC pizza joint that’s been around for years. This coal oven pizzeria has been satisfying pizza lovers since 1931, so you know you can trust it for an incredible classic pie. Grimaldi’s is known for its thin crust, along with its delicious topping combinations and mouth-watering slices. Additionally, Grimaldi’s has an outdoor cafe and bar area, giving it a rustic old-school feel.
- Katz’s Delicatessen
No list of classic NYC restaurants can be complete without Katz’s Delicatessen. This iconic deli has been serving the classic sandwich since 1888. With its rows of deli-style sandwiches, mostly famous for its pastrami and corned beef, Katz’s is the perfect spot for an old-school NYC sandwich. The restaurant also features an inviting, old-style atmosphere and a great vibe.
- Carmine’s
Carmine’s is a beloved Italian restaurant in New York City. This classic spot has been around since 1919 and has been pleasing families with its generous portions and top-notch Italian fare. The restaurant features traditional Italian-American dishes, from its classic spiedino to its eggplant parmigiana. Not to mention, the atmosphere of Carmine’s is energetic and typical of an old-school restaurant.
- MacDougal Street Cottage
For a romantic old-school dinner, check out the MacDougal Street Cottage. This cozy restaurant has been around since 1923 and is known for its classic American dishes. From its filet mignon to its pork chops, MacDougal Street Cottage has been pleasing locals with its delicious food and romantic atmosphere. The restaurant is located on a quiet side street and has a rustic, old-school vibe that makes it perfect for a vintage night out.
- J.G. Melon
The last restaurant on this list is J.G. Melon, a well-loved American spot in the city. J.G. Melon has been pleasing locals with its traditional burgers, sides, and chowder since 1972. The restaurant also features a quaint pub-like atmosphere, perfect for recreating the classic NYC diner experience.
Whether you’re a New Yorker or just visiting the Big Apple, make sure to check out these classic old-school restaurants for a beautiful night out. From the iconic Ebinger’s to the well-known Peter Luger Steak House, you’ll get to experience the real classic atmosphere of New York City. Delight in the nostalgia and make sure to bring somebody you love, an old-school outing just isn’t complete without them.
